The Life of the Church Lesson 44 of 56

Pastoral Care and Counseling

The Shepherding Ministry

Sign In to Track Progress

Introduction: The Shepherd's Heart

The most common biblical image for church leadership is the shepherd. God Himself is the Great Shepherd (Psalm 23; Ezekiel 34). Jesus is the Good Shepherd who lays down His life for the sheep (John 10:11). Elders are charged to "shepherd the flock of God that is among you" (1 Peter 5:2). The very word "pastor" comes from the Latin pastor—shepherd.

Shepherding is not primarily about teaching, administrating, or leading meetings—though it includes all of these. Shepherding is about knowing and caring for individual sheep. It is personal, relational, and often messy. The shepherd knows the sheep by name (John 10:3), leads them to green pastures, protects them from wolves, binds their wounds, and goes after the one that strays. Pastoral care is this shepherding ministry applied to the life of the local church.

Elements of Pastoral Care

Visitation. The tradition of pastoral visitation—the pastor going to the homes, hospitals, and workplaces of his members—has deep roots in Reformed practice. Richard Baxter devoted much of The Reformed Pastor to the necessity of home visitation, arguing that a pastor who only preaches from the pulpit but never enters the homes of his people is not truly shepherding them. While the logistics of visitation vary by congregation size, the principle remains: pastoral care requires personal contact, not just public preaching.

Crisis ministry. Pastors are often the first responders in spiritual and emotional crises: a death in the family, a cancer diagnosis, a marriage in crisis, a prodigal child, job loss, depression, or spiritual doubt. The pastor's role in crisis is not to fix the problem but to be present—to embody Christ's compassion, to pray, to listen, to weep with those who weep, and to point the sufferer to the promises of God that sustain when everything else fails.

Milestone ministry. The pastor walks with members through life's milestones: births, baptisms, professions of faith, weddings, anniversaries, retirements, and funerals. These occasions are not mere formalities—they are moments of profound theological significance where the gospel intersects with the deepest experiences of human life.

Preventive care. The wise pastor does not wait for crises to engage. Regular check-ins, meals with families, premarital counseling, new member assimilation, and ongoing accountability relationships all serve to strengthen members before trials come. Prevention is less dramatic than crisis intervention but far more effective.

Biblical Counseling

The church has a vital role in counseling—helping members navigate the struggles of life through the application of Scripture, the power of prayer, and the support of community. The biblical counseling movement, pioneered by Jay Adams and developed by many others, has argued that Scripture is sufficient for addressing the spiritual dimensions of human problems and that the church—not the therapist's office—should be the primary context for soul care.

The strengths of biblical counseling are significant: it takes Scripture seriously as the authority for life and godliness, it addresses sin directly rather than merely managing symptoms, it grounds hope in the gospel rather than in therapeutic technique, and it keeps soul care within the community of the church rather than outsourcing it to secular professionals.

Knowing Your Limits

Pastors must know the limits of their competence. While every pastor should be able to provide basic spiritual counsel, some situations require expertise that most pastors do not possess: severe mental illness, psychotic episodes, suicidal ideation, complex trauma, substance addiction, and neurological conditions. In these cases, referral to a qualified Christian mental health professional is not a failure of faith but an act of wisdom and love. The pastor who insists on counseling beyond his competence may cause more harm than the condition itself. The best approach is collaborative: the pastor provides spiritual care while a qualified professional addresses the clinical dimensions of the problem.

Pastoral Care Is Not the Pastor's Alone

One of the most damaging assumptions in contemporary church life is that pastoral care is exclusively the pastor's job. In a church of any significant size, one pastor (or even a team of pastors) cannot possibly provide adequate care for every member. The New Testament envisions pastoral care as a shared ministry of the entire body.

Elders share in the shepherding work (1 Peter 5:1–4; Acts 20:28). Deacons provide mercy ministry and practical support. Mature members bear one another's burdens (Galatians 6:2). Older women mentor younger women (Titus 2:3–4). The pastor's role is to model, train, and coordinate care—not to monopolize it.

A healthy church develops a culture of care—where members naturally notice when someone is absent, where meals appear at the door of the grieving, where hospital visits are made not only by the pastor but by fellow members, and where no one suffers alone because the body is alert to the needs of its parts.

Equipping the Body to Care

Practical steps for developing shared pastoral care include: training elders and deacons in basic visitation and counseling skills; creating care teams that respond to specific needs (meals, transportation, childcare); assigning elders to shepherd specific groups of families; training lay members in basic grief support and crisis response; and consistently teaching from the pulpit that care is the whole body's responsibility, not just the staff's.

Conclusion: The Smell of Sheep

Pope Francis famously told his priests to have "the smell of the sheep"—to be so close to their people that the life of the flock clings to them. Whatever one thinks of Francis's theology, the image is powerful. The pastor who only preaches and administrates but never visits, never weeps with the grieving, never sits beside the hospital bed, never enters the mess of his people's lives is not a shepherd—he is a lecturer.

Pastoral care is demanding, draining, and often thankless work. It rarely produces visible results. It cannot be measured by metrics or reported in annual reviews. But it is the heart of the pastoral calling—the slow, patient, costly work of knowing and caring for the sheep that the Chief Shepherd has entrusted to the under-shepherd's care.

"I am the good shepherd. I know my own and my own know me."

— John 10:14
💬

Discussion Questions

  1. Richard Baxter argued that a pastor who only preaches from the pulpit but never enters the homes of his people is not truly shepherding them. How realistic is this expectation in today's church, especially in larger congregations? What adaptations of the visitation model could preserve its pastoral intent?
  2. The lesson acknowledges both the strengths of biblical counseling and the need for referral to qualified professionals in cases of severe mental illness, complex trauma, or addiction. How should a church navigate the relationship between pastoral counseling and professional therapy? What criteria should a pastor use to determine when referral is appropriate?
  3. The lesson argues that pastoral care is the responsibility of the whole body, not just the pastor. What prevents most churches from developing this culture of shared care? What would it look like in your congregation for every member to see themselves as a caregiver?